Refusing a Chemical Test in Minnesota
There's a persistent myth that refusing the breath test is a smart way to deny the state evidence. In Minnesota, it's a trap. Test refusal is itself a gross misdemeanor — separate from the DWI charge — and it triggers a longer license revocation than a high-BAC test result. For most people, refusing makes things worse, not better.
What 'refusal' means under Minnesota law
Refusal includes outright saying no, hanging up on the implied-consent advisory, asking to call a lawyer indefinitely without completing the test, or providing inadequate breath samples (insufficient volume) without medical justification. The officer's report flags any of these as refusal.
You're entitled to a reasonable attempt to consult an attorney before testing — typically 15–30 minutes — but you cannot use that consultation period to indefinitely stall. The phone call right is real but bounded.
Refusal penalties are harsher than a DWI
First-offense refusal: charged as a 3rd Degree DWI gross misdemeanor (up to 1 year jail, $3,000 fine), even if you have no prior DWI. A clean first-offense DWI test result is only a 4th degree misdemeanor (90 days, $1,000).
License revocation for refusal: 1 year minimum on a first offense. License revocation for a clean first-offense test failure: 90 days. The refusal multiplies your license loss by four.
When refusal might still make sense
Two scenarios where refusal can be a reasonable risk: (1) you know your BAC is way above 0.16 and your case already has felony or repeat-offense exposure — at that point the marginal harm of a refusal is smaller, and (2) you're a CDL holder whose career ends with a recorded BAC over 0.04.
These are calls to make with a lawyer, not at the roadside. For a typical first-time, BAC-likely-under-0.15 stop, take the test. Refusing pushes a misdemeanor into a gross misdemeanor for no benefit.
Defending a refusal charge
Refusal cases turn on whether the implied-consent advisory was correctly read. The advisory must inform you that Minnesota law requires the test, that refusal is a crime, and that you have a right to consult counsel. Skip any of those and the refusal can be reduced or dismissed.
Other defenses: medical inability to provide breath (asthma, recent surgery), language barrier without proper translation, officer denied the right to a meaningful attorney consultation, or no probable cause for the arrest in the first place.
Frequently asked questions
Is refusing a breath test a crime in Minnesota?
Yes. Minn. Stat. § 169A.20 subd. 2 makes test refusal a separate gross-misdemeanor crime — charged as 3rd Degree DWI on a first offense.
What is the penalty for refusing a breath test in Minnesota?
First-offense refusal: up to 1 year jail, up to $3,000 fine, and 1-year minimum license revocation. Penalties escalate with priors.
Can I refuse the roadside breath test in Minnesota?
The roadside Preliminary Breath Test (PBT) is voluntary and refusing it is not a crime. The post-arrest evidentiary breath test at the station is the one whose refusal is criminalized.
Do I have a right to a lawyer before the breath test?
Yes — limited. You can make a reasonable attempt to consult counsel (typically 15–30 minutes). You cannot use the call to indefinitely delay; that becomes refusal.
Can a Minnesota refusal charge be dismissed?
Often, yes — most commonly when the implied-consent advisory was botched, the stop lacked reasonable suspicion, the arrest lacked probable cause, or the attorney-consultation right was denied.